The pencil line
By long convention, a finished print is marked in pencil in the margin below the image: the edition number at the left, the title in the centre (often omitted), and the artist's signature, sometimes with the year, at the right. Pencil is used because it sits in the fibres of the paper, cannot easily be lifted, and does not fade or bleed the way many inks do.
These are conventions, not laws. Plenty of print club editions are signed on the back, stamped rather than signed, or marked on an accompanying card instead - especially small-format riso and postcard prints where there is no margin to write in. What matters is that the club is clear about what you are getting.
What "12/50" means
The bottom number is the size of the edition: fifty impressions were made and approved, and the artist commits to making no more of this image in this form. The top number identifies this impression within that edition - number twelve of fifty.
It is a common belief that low numbers are better. For most prints made today, they are not. Prints are usually numbered after the whole run has dried, from a stack, so "1" was not necessarily pulled first. The idea dates from older intaglio printing, where a copper plate could wear slightly over a long run and early impressions were crisper. With screenprints, linocuts, risograph and letterpress at print-club edition sizes, there is no meaningful difference between 3/50 and 47/50.
The number worth paying attention to is the bottom one. An edition of 25 is scarcer than one of 250, and the price usually reflects it.
AP, PP, HC and the other marks
In place of a number, some prints carry letters. These are outside the numbered edition, but made at the same time and to the same standard.
| Mark | Stands for | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| AP or A/P (also E.A.) | Artist's proof (épreuve d'artiste) | Impressions the artist keeps. Conventionally around a tenth of the edition size. Often sold later, sometimes at a premium. |
| PP | Printer's proof | Given to the printer when the artist works with a print studio or master printer. |
| BAT | Bon à tirer ("good to pull") | The approved proof that the whole edition is matched against. Usually just one. |
| TP | Trial proof | A working proof made while colours and composition were being decided. Often unique, and sometimes different from the final edition. |
| HC | Hors commerce ("not for trade") | Impressions set aside for exhibition or archive, not meant for sale. |
| 1/1, or "unique" | A one-off | Monotypes, monoprints and hand-coloured variants. There is only one. |
| VE | Variable edition | Every impression differs - different colours, hand-finishing or collage - though the matrix is shared. |
Limited editions and open editions
A limited edition has a fixed size, stated on the print. When it sells out, that image is finished in that form. An open edition has no cap - the artist can keep printing as long as people want it. Open editions are usually unnumbered, and are common for postcards, stickers and many digital prints.
Neither is better. Open editions keep good work affordable; limited editions give you scarcity. What you want from a print club is honesty: does the club say how many were made, and whether the screen, block or file is retired afterwards? The good ones always do.
Original print or reproduction?
This is the distinction that matters most, and the one listings most often blur.
An original print is an artwork conceived as a print. The artist makes the matrix - the screen, the carved block, the etched plate, the colour separations for a risograph - and the print is the finished work. There is no "real" painting behind it. Screenprints, linocuts, woodcuts, etchings, lithographs, letterpress and artist-separated risograph prints are all original prints. Our field guide to printmaking techniques explains each.
A reproduction is a print of an artwork that exists in another form, usually a painting or a digital illustration. The best are giclée or archival pigment prints: high-resolution inkjet on cotton paper with lightfast inks, which can look superb and last a long time. A signature and a number do not turn a reproduction into an original print; they make it a signed, limited reproduction.
Look for the words on the listing. "Hand-pulled", "screenprint", "linocut", "relief print" and "risograph" describe how an original print was made. "Giclée", "fine art print", "digital print" and "archival pigment print" describe reproductions. Reproductions are a perfectly good thing to collect - they just should not be priced or described as something else.
Signatures, chop marks and certificates
- A pencil signature means the artist handled and approved that impression. A printed signature (part of the image) means nothing of the sort.
- A chop mark or blind stamp is a small embossed seal pressed into the margin by the studio or printer. It identifies where the print was made.
- A certificate of authenticity is useful paperwork but not proof on its own; anyone can print a certificate.
For a print club collector, the best provenance is the simplest: keep the note that came with each print, and the club's description of the edition. Together they record who made it, how, when and in what number - which is everything a future owner, framer or valuer will ask.
Keeping a record of your collection
A monthly club adds twelve prints a year. A simple list - artist, title, club, technique, edition number, date received, where it is now - takes a minute per print and saves a great deal of guessing later. Write the same details lightly in pencil on the back of the backing board, never on the print itself.
And store the ones not on the wall properly; our guide to storing and framing prints covers the materials that will not damage them.